Saturday, April 17, 2010


<-- Jonathan helping us out in the Marine Science Lab! These two jars are the water obtained from the Marina.
Below: Measuring the salinity of the water from the Marina.

Measuring the temperature of the Marina water.

Below: On our way to the Marina in the boat.





<-- Secci Disk at the Marina!


Below: CO2 titration









<-- Hard at work in the Marine Science Lab.









<-- Titrating more CO2 levels.

project report

Research Question: Why and to what effect, do the different water composition and properties change from the docks to Marinna?

Hypothesis: The water at the Marinna has higher carbon dioxide content, less transparency, less oxygen content and higher salinity.

Content:
introduction
methodology
apparatus needed

Introduction:
The aim of our project was to see the variation in the different water at the Docks and at the Marina. We were curious about the difference affected by pollution at the Marina since threre are more boats parking and passing by. Ultimately, this will affect the aqua life in the area and help us to conclude the best way to conserve and protect our ocean.

Properties of water that we looked at:
Temperature, salinity, transparency, dissolved oxygen and dissolved carbon dioxide content in water.

Experiement:
1)Surface temperature(degree C)
In order to obtain the temperature of the water in both the Marina and the docks, we connect the thermometer to logger pro and find the average temperature within 30 seconds(however, temperature will drop due to the loss of kinetic energy over time).

Results:
Docks: 10.7
Marina: 12

Source of error:We took the temperature of the water at the docks, how ever, the Marina water was transferred back to the Lab, therefore allowing for time for the temperature to fall.

2)Salinity (ppt)
Again we connect the Salinity Sensor to the logger pro and measure the salinity over a certain period of time until it stabalized.

Results(at the surface):
Docks: 30.7
Marina: 30.2

Source of Error: The measurements were only taken at the surface of the water.

3)transparency (m)
We lowered the Secci Disk into the water at the docks until it dissapeared and then we raised it again until we could see it. At the exact point that we saw the disk again, we marked the rope and measured it. The same was done at the Marina in between the boats.

Results (m)
Docks: 2.5
Marina: 1.3

Source of Error: Some people can see more than others so there was a variation in what was the actual transparency. Also, there is the uncertainty of the measuring instrument used to measure the length of the rope that was under water.
4)Dissolved oxygen content
By connecting the oxymeter to logger pro, we can see the amount of dissolved oxygen in water.

results(mg/L)
Docks:10.8
Marina:13

5) Dissolved CO2 (mg/L)
Using 25ml of sample water, we did a titration of the solution HI 3818-0 against water. The colour chagne from colourless to pink determine the end point of the titration and thus the CO2 content.The remaining solution times a certain ratio will give us the amount of dissolved CO2 in water.

Results:
Sea Table: 10.7 (+/-0.5)
Marina:6.3 (+/-0.5)

Source of error: The end point is difficult to determine due to the minor change of colour. Moreover, the water sample taken for docks is from sea table. Therefore, it is not a completely arrurate representation. Another source of error would be the transportation of the water back to the Lab, and in the process some of the CO2 would have been converted to carbonic acid. As for other discrepincies, please refer to the previous entries.

Analysis:

The average temperature at the two stations were relatively similar where as the salinity at the Marina was less than that measured at the Docks. Also, the transparency at the Marina was significantly less than that at the Docks. The level of CO2 at the docks was significantly more than that at the Marina. The level of O2 is higher in the Marina than that of the Docks.

**We must keep in mind that the Docks results and the Marina Results were taken on different days.

Interpretation:

We believe that the salinity was less at the Marina because of the rainfall the previous night. The transparency at the Marina was less than at the docks possibly because of pollution from the boats and the sewage drained. CO2 content at the docks was more because circulation and the possibility of more aquatic plants utalizing the CO2 for photosynthesis. Dissolved CO2 level and O2 oppose each other in the different locations. The higher O2 level in the Marina further proves that there are more aquatic plants in the Marina that release the oxygen. This is supported by the smaller amount of CO2 found at the Marina. The opposite is true of the Docks, implying there is less aqutic plants.

Conclusion:

Through the information gathered, we have come to reject our initial hypothesis. There seems to be more aquatic plants at the Marina than there is at the Docks because of the higher oxygen content. We believe that the sewage that is drained into the water at the docks aids the aquatic plants to grow and thus there is higher production of O2.

Minor Glitch

We had planned to take the 2nd set of data at Racerocks, but we are unable to go there today.

As a compromise, we have decided to take the results from the marina. Also we cannot see the organisms because of the water clarity. This has forced us to adapt our research question to "Why, and to what effect, does the different water composition and properties change from the Docks to the Marina?"

We will wait a while until the water clarity improves and allows us to count the organisms in the Docks in a limited area.

Hypothesis: The water at the Marina will have more CO2 content, less transparency, less oxygen content, and higher salinity.

Our theory is that there is more pollution at the Marina than at the Docks due to the boats and potential leakage there might be.

Apr 17 9:35am G4 project day!

We are measuring the amount of CO2 dissolved in water. Firstly, we add a drop of phenolphthalein indicator to the water collected from Pedder Bay. If the solution remains colourless, we then do a titration of HI 3818-0 solution(from the equipment kit provided) against water. From the amount of solution remains in the titration syringe, we times that to a certain ratio to determine the amount of CO2. However, depending on the amount of water, it shows a different range of the amount of CO2. Our results obtained is different as well.
Amount of water: 5ml
range of measurement of CO2:0-100 mg/L
result obtained: 0 mg/L

Amount of water:10ml
range of measurement:0-50mg/L
result obtained:5.5mg/L

amount of water: 25ml
range of measurement: 0-35mg/L
result of obtained: 8.05mg/L

amount of water: 50ml
range of measurement:0-10mg/L
result obtained: 10mg/L

Because of the descrepancies of the results, we decided to repeat some of the experiment. After doing so, we have concluded that the most accurate range of measurement was the 25mL amount of water. This proved to be more consistant with the results.

Improvement: Because we took the water from different locations at the Dock, we decided to take the remaining expirements from the water table. These came to match with the 25mL result from the Dock.

25 mL Sea Table:
0.30(mg/L) x 35 = 10.5 (mg/L)
0.32 (mg/L) x 35 = 11.2 (mg/L)

The variation that we see within the experiments could be due to the agitation that the test samples were put through. The distance from the docks to the lab may have agitated the sample enough to make the inconsistancies noted in the above results. How ever, when we took the samples from the Sea Table in the Lab, the results seemed to be more congruent. This can be due to less agitation and thus release of CO2 content. Also, there is less variation in the Sea Table, because it had rained the night before and this can be added and mixed into the solution of the bay water, where as the Sea Table remains constant.

Other Results for the Docks:
Salinity: 0m- 30.7 ppt, 1m- 30.6ppt , 2m- 30.8ppt, 3m- 30.9ppt.
Temperature (degrees C): 0m- 10.7, 1m - 10.6, 2m- 9.8, 3m- 9.33
Average Dissolved O2: 10.8 (mg/L)
Transparency: 2.5m

Thursday, April 15, 2010

April 15th 2010 @ approximately 3.30 pm

Our group completed part of the experimental process down at the docks.

Using a Secci Disk, we were able to find the transparency of the water just off the docks. We also measured the salinity, temperature and O2 content in the same spot.

We will be coming back to the docks on Saturday to count the algae that are growing on the side of the docks to compare it with the algae found at racerocks.

We will run the same tests at Racerocks on Saturday.

Monday, April 12, 2010

Group 4 Update!

Anthony, Antsa, Amanda and Hailey have decided on our research project!

We are going to be looking at the differences in composition and clarity of water at Racerocks vs. in the bay and comparing that to the organism concentrations.

We have sent Jonathan an email about the supplies w require and have talked with Laura about a trip to Racerocks on the day of the project.

Thanks for following!